Boca Raton 561-297-3000 Davie 954-236-1000 Dania Beach 954-924-7000 Fort Lauderdale 954-236-1000 Jupiter 561-799-8500 Treasure Coast 772-873-3300
 
  FAU Home / COE Home / CoE Org Home /Contact a COE Program Advisor  

BOARD OF EXAMINERS REPORT

N C A T E


National Council for Accreditation off Teacher Education

Continuing Accreditation Visit to:

Florida Atlantic University
Boca Raton, FL

April 1-5, 2000


NCATE Board of Examiners Team:
Maryann Mannning, Chari
Gordon Horgen
John Marsteller
Lani Martin
Carrie Robinson

Florida State Team:
Robert Vos, Chair
Bernadine Bolden
William H. Caldwell
Nancy McAleer

Florida Department of Education Consultant:
Tom Hobbs

Florida Board of Regents Representative:
Calr Blackman

Florida Education Association Representative:
Betty Burden-Lee


Report Contents

Part I: Introduction

Part II: Findings for Each Standards Category

Part III: Sources of Evidence


PART I 
INTRODUCTION 


The University Founded in 1964 in Boca Raton, Florida Atlantic University became the fifth university in the Florida public system. The University is responsible for providing academic programs and public service to the counties of Palm Beach, Broward, Indian River, Martin, St. Lucie, and Okeechobee with a total population of approximately three million people. The threefold mission of the University includes teaching, research, and public service in the expanding urban environment of southeast Florida.

The original and main campus of Florida Atlantic University is the Boca Raton Campus which is located on 850 acres of land three miles from the Atlantic Ocean. The campus is located on a former U.S. Army airfield and is inhabited by a variety of wildlife, including burrowing owls. The number of buildings on the Boca Raton Campus has grown to over seventy, including the College of Education Building which was completed in 1994, The university has expanded to include six other campuses including those in Broward County (Davie Campus), the Northern campuses in Jupiter (John D. MacArthur Campus), and Port St. Lucie (Treasure Coast Campus). The team visited all campuses (Boca Raton, MacArthur, Treasure Coast and Davie) with College of Education programs. 

Over twenty thousand students are enrolled and nearly four thousand degrees are awarded annually. In addition to the College of Education, the university includes the College of Architecture; Urban and Public Affairs; the Dorothy F. Schmidt College of Arts and Letters; the Colleges of Business, Engineering, Honors, Liberal Arts, and Nursing and the Charles E. Schmidt College of Science. There are over 800 full-time faculty members and nearly 3,500 full-time employees. The current fund revenues for 1998-99 were $239,053,642. Currently, the university offers 57 Bachelor's, 50 Master's, 3 Specialist and 15 Doctoral degrees. 

The five-story Wimberly Library has a collection of 725,800 volumes, 2.5 million microfilms, and subscriptions to 4,300 scholarly journals and other serials. The library also houses one of the nation's top Judaica collections in addition to a large collection of monographs, serials, and other academic resources. The Davie campus has a shared library with Broward Community College. The Treasure Coast Campus utilizes the St. Lucie West Library which is supported by St. Lucie County, Indian River Community College, and Florida Atlantic University. The library on the MacArthur Campus is shared with the community college. 

The College of Education 

The following is a statement from the graduate catalog: "The College of Education is dedicated to the education of educational professionals; individuals with a sound knowledge base built on the best available research, theory, and practical applications; individuals with high standards of ethical behavior and a commitment to excellence and continued learning." This mission is carried out through the departments of Counselor Education, Educational Leadership, Exceptional Student Education, Health Sciences, Educational Technology and Research, and Teacher  Education.

There has been a 43.5% growth in students enrolled in programs in the College of Education since the last NCATE visit. During the 1993-94 academic year there were ,328.9 annualized student FTEs compared to 1998-99 when there were 1,907 annualized student FTES.

Degree programs offered are offered at the bachelor's, master's, specialist, and doctoral levels. Undergraduate teacher education programs include Elementary Education with ESOL endorsement; Secondary Education with certification programs in English 6-8, Social Sciences 6-8, Biology 6-12, Chemistry 6-12, Physics 6-12, Mathematics 6-12, Art K-12, Music K-12, French K-12, German K-12, and Spanish K- 12; Teaching English to Speakers of Other Language (TESOL); and Exceptional Student Education. Health Sciences programs include a Bachelor of Science in Education with a Major in Exercise Science/Wellness Education; and Bachelor of Science in Health Science.

Undergraduate certification programs include elementary education with ESOL endorsement, exceptional student education, and medical technology. Graduate certification programs include counselor education, early childhood education, educational leadership, elementary education, exceptional student education, social foundations, and speech-language pathology. Non-certification programs include the Bachelor of Science Degree in Medical Technology, Master's Degree in Science in Exercise Science and Wellness Education, Master's of Science Degree in Communications Disorders, and the Master's of Science in Speech Pathology and Audiology.

All undergraduate and graduate programs except graduate and undergraduate exercise science and wellness (offered only at Davie Campus) are offered on the Boca Raton campus.

Undergraduate, elementary education and graduate educational leadership programs are offered on all four campuses. Counselor education and undergraduate exceptional education are offered at three campuses (Boca Raton, MacArthur and Davie). Undergraduate secondary education, graduate communication disorders, graduate reading, graduate elementary, graduate curriculum and instruction are offered at two campuses (Boca Raton and Davie). faculty and adjuncts.

These courses are taught by full-time Most departments offer a few courses via distance learning. No complete program is offered via distance learning but graduate exceptional student education and varying exceptionalities programs are being planned in collaboration with other universities in the Florida State University System.

The Genesis Teacher Education Project is an experimental teacher education five year program that offers a bachelor's and master's degree in both the liberal arts and education. Genesis has a collaborative partnership with A.D. Henderson University ~ School and the School Districts of Palm Beach County, Martin County and St. Lucie County. Students receive certification in elementary, middle school, secondary education and ESOL.

There are 177 full-time education faculty, 72% more than in 1995, and 200 adjunct faculty members. Fifty one percent of the current faculty have been hired since 1995. The faculty has received many awards from learned societies for research and scholarship.

The College of Education has developed twelve very successful professional development schools (Genesis Academy for Teacher Excellence) which include seven public elementary schools, one elementary/middle school, two public middle schools, and one middle/senior high school, and one high school. This network of professional schools is located in three counties. Currently, there are plans to expand the number of professional development schools. The Karen Slattery Educational Research Center for Child Development and A.D. Henderson University School provide many rich experiences for students in early childhood and elementary education.

Major changes the School of Education has made since the last NCATE visit:

·        hired 45 new faculty members

·        expanded programs

·        increased enrollment dramatically at all campuses

·        reorganized academic units

·        restructured educational leadership, teacher education, and counselor education

·        established faculty assembly

·        expanded professional schools

·        established the Secondary Teacher Education Coordinating Committee

This was a continuing visit conducted by a team of five NCATE BOE members with one observer and a team of four faculty members from Florida higher education institutions, one representative of the Florida Department of Education and one representative from the Florida Board of Regents.


Back to Top


PART II
FINDINGS FOR EACH CATEGORY OF STANDARDS


CATEGORY I: DESIGN OF PROFESSIONAL EDUCATION


A. Observations

The goal of the College of Education at Florida Atlantic University is to prepare professionals to effectively meet the challenges and needs of teacher education candidates in the context of their work with students and families manifesting linguistic diversity, cultural diversity, learning, and behavioral diversity in an increasingly interpendent and rapidly changing world. In order to meet the aforementioned goal, the College of Education articulated as its conceptual framework, Professional Preparation for a Diverse Society. The College of Education's conceptual framework includes three specific academic components in the preparation of professionals: foundational requirements, experiential learning, and professional knowledge. The conceptual framework is clearly articulated and does appear in some documents, i.e., on the College of Education0s website, in some course syllabi, and in the field experience handbooks that are distributed to all students enrolled in field experience courses. The conceptual framework is not readily observable in places such as student teaching handbooks, the catalogs [undergraduate and graduate], and the College of Education brochure. Some facu4 and students did not appear to value or be knowledgeable about the Conceptual Framework.

Extensive informal collaboration takes place between faculty in the College of Education and the faculty in other colleges who teach content studies. The Secondary Teacher Education Coordinating Council has been established since the last NCATE visit.

Technology is integrated into every program. Alumni, students, and faculty report that technology is a valued and important part of their collection of teaching techniques. Candidates learn to integrate what they have learned in their field experiences which are carefully planned and sequenced. Practica prior to student teaching are part of methods classes as well as specifically designed field experiences and take place in a variety of settings. Evaluation forms for candidates documenting early field experiences, practical and student teaching are extensive and spell out the expectations and accomplishments of the candidates. Linguistic and cultural diversity are an integral part of the experiences. Student teaching is a one-semester experience unless the candidate is enrolled in the Genesis project in which case the candidate serves as a paid intern during the fifth year.

Advanced programs include master's degree programs in Educational Leadership, Counselor Education, Curriculum and Instruction, Reading Education, Exceptional Student Education, and Health Sciences. The Educational Leadership Department has used a review process, major national reports, and standards of review agencies and learned societies which have resulted in extensive changes. Using the College of Education0s conceptual framework, the department has developed its own curriculum. There is an increased emphasis on experiential learning, technology, and communication. The master0s and doctoral programs have been redesigned; however, little focus has been given to cultural and linguistic diversity. It is not written, however, professors state that there is a departmental culture of honoring diversity. Although It is stated in the College of Education Conceptual Framework and repeated in the Education Leadership Department0s Conceptual Framework Connection to Program's matrix, syllabi and bibliographies show few connections to diversity issues. Students report, however, that classes do address issues of diversity. Although it is not written, professors state that there is a departmental culture of honoring diversity adhered to by the entire department. Issues of diversity are addressed in courses throughout the Graduate School Counselor program. The master's in Graduate School Counseling requires a course, (Counseling Special Needs Populations), which deals with issues of minority, bilingual, handicapped, and other special needs group.

Cultural and linguistic diversity are threaded throughout the teacher education program. However, the Secondary Teacher Education Coordinating Committee exhibits little knowledge of the Conceptual Framework. This committee is made up of faculty and administrators from outside the College of Education who teach the content for secondary certification.

Adjunct and new faculty receive a handbook which covers issues such as preparation of the syllabus, professionalism, textbooks, emergency procedures, audio- visual procedures and contact people. Mentors are assigned to new faculty to assist them in the promotion and tenure process. Detailed outlines for the required portfolios which faculty must submit for tenure and promotion are provided to each new faculty member. Department chairs observe new and adjunct faculty members ' classes. A three year review prepares the faculty member for the tenure and promotion process which comes at the sixth year. Department chairs review student evaluations each semester and consult with faculty if assessment indicates changes should be made.

The field experience requirements in all programs have been increased since the last NCATE visit. In Counselor Education, the field experience requirement has been changed from the old requirement of 100 practicum hours to one 150 hour practicum plus a 600 hour internship. In Educational Leadership at the master's level students are now required to complete a 100 hour internship, as well as participate in simulations and case study analysis in other courses. At the Specialist level students are required to take 9 hours of experiential learning and each student must produce a Learning Portfolio as a requirement for the internship. The 9 hour requirement consists of a 6 hour internship and a 3 hour field project. In Exceptional Student Education students have numerous opportunities for practical experience, including observation requirements, methods courses that require students to work with individual K- 12 students. Additionally, all ESE students at the master's level complete either a 3 credit hour or a 6 credit hour internship. In Teacher Education clinical requirements exist in each program, the amount depending upon the emphasis area.

B. Weaknesses Corrected since the Previous Visit

Standard I.A. The knowledge base is not clearly articulated across all programs within the unit. A new conceptual framework has been developed and includes all programs.

Standard I.C. [Previous Standard I.D]. Professional education faculty do not collaborate with faculty who teach the specialty studies. Informal discussions are held and advisors collaborate.

Standard I.H [Previous Standard II.A] Advanced. The unit does not assure that all advanced programs at each degree level include clinical and field-based experiences.

All programs include required clinical and field-based experiences.

Weakness Continued from the Previous Visit

None were cited.

New Weakness

Standard I.A. The conceptual framework is not fully infused into the culture of the College of Education.

Many individuals both within and outside the College of Education are unaware of the conceptual framework and it is not included in some course syllabi and some documents.


Back to Top


CATEGORY II: CANDIDATES IN PROFESSIONAL EDUCATION


A. Observations

The criteria for admission to initial and advanced programs in the College of Education are detailed in the university catalogues, as well as in brochures for each specific program within the unit. The recruitment efforts have been successful in attracting high quality candidates to the programs of the unit. To assure basic skills competence, initial teacher preparation candidates must have an overall grade point average of 2.5 or higher on a 4.0 scale, and pass the College Level Academic Skills Test (CLAST) with scores of 295 in mathematics, reading, English, and an essay score of 6. Furthermore, they must have an ACT score of 20 or higher or an SAT score of 960 or higher. Over the past two years, the College of Education entering student demographics indicate that 60 % of the candidates held an Associate of Arts Degree from a Florida community college and eight percent held a Bachelor0s Degree. Two candidates held a rnaster0s degree before entering the prograrn. Of those entering the college, more than 35% of the students had a GPA of 3.5 or higher, and their average age was twenty-six. Applicants for admission to a graduate degree-granting program of the university must meet the minimum standards set forth by the Florida Board of Regents. The candidate must have a OBO (3.0 on a 4.0 scale) average or better when registered as an upper division student working for a baccalaureate degree. Alternately, the candidate must have obtained a minimum combined score of 1000 (quantitative and verbal) on the Graduate Record Exam (GRE) or a graduate degree from a regionally accredited institution.

The candidate must also meet the specific requirements set by the program.

The College of Education works toward recruiting, admitting, and retaining a diverse student body. The unit in concert with the Florida Atlantic University has instituted a variety of initiatives to meet this goal. The University established a Director of Development position for the College of Education to secure endowments and grants. The Florida Department of Education offers financial assistance to minority students through its Bright Futures Scholarship Program. The University also has specific scholarships designated for academically gifted Spanish and African-American students. A grant proposal, "Recruiting for Gender Equity and Diversity in Teacher Education", has been submitted to the University Provost. The College of Education Director of Academic and Student Services meets with students and counselors at the community colleges to encourage diverse students to enter the teacher program, The appointment of a minority Associate Director for Academic and Student Services provides minority students with a role model and person with whom they feel comfortable discussing their progress.

To admit high potential minority applicants, the college has employed the 10% rule for admitting promising applicants who do not meet the Board of Regent's minimum requirements for admission to graduate school. A "Grow Your Own" program provides financial assistance to minority students who want to pursue a graduate degree. Supplementary student services exist through the Office of Multicultural Affairs to increase retention rates of minority and other special student populations.

The Academic Enhancement Programs, Cultural Diversity Week, Math /English Labs, Book Loan Program, Counseling Program, and Mentoring Program accomplish the overall goal of retention.

The percentage of minority enrollment in the undergraduate program rose from 11.3% in 1995 to 25.8% in 1999, and during the same time period the percentage of initiatives have had a positive effect by raising the percentage of minority students enrolled in the College.

Academic advising is an integral part of the unit0s program. Once complete records are on file in the Office for Academic and Student Services, entering candidates are assigned advisors and formally begin their program. Candidates enrolling in content area. Advisors are available to the candidates on a walk-in basis.

Once admission requirements to graduate programs are met, students are complete a planned program of study. At the specialist and doctoral levels, candidates are assigned a faculty advisor and additional committee members are added. Testimonials from students were very positive concerning the accessibility and helpfulness of the advisors.

A student may sign up for classes at any of the campuses, but all records are kept at the campus nearest to the student0s residence. A back-up of all records is electronically kept on the mainframe in the Office for Academic and Student Services at the Boca Raton Campus. This centralization of files enables faculty to monitor a candidate0s progress.

Student's progress in initial and advanced courses is monitored using multiple sources of data as they move toward mastery of established exit criteria. Student progress in field experiences is evaluated using a check list of performance during classroom experiences. Special requirements for enrollment in student teaching must be met before the candidate is allowed to begin an internship. Elementary and secondary majors must present passing scores on the Florida Teacher Certification Examination, a GPA of 2.5, and security clearance. The student teaching experience is monitored by a university supervisor and a cooperating teacher who has completed state mandated clinical educator training. The student's progress is monitored in a variety of ways including written forms, conferences, self reflection, demonstrations and other measures. The candidates culminate their professional experience by developing a portfolio which will provide a tool for authentic assessment of their professional growth. The graduating students must meet the state testing requirements for licensure by having already achieved passing scores on the College Level Academic Skills Test (CLAST) and on the Florida Teacher Certification Examination.

Cooperating teachers, school administrators, candidates, and graduates value the quality of the teacher preparation programs at the Florida Atlantic University College of Education.

The Florida Atlantic University0s November 30, 1999 Institutional Program Evaluation Plan (IPEP) to the Florida Department of Education reports that the FAU graduates had a 100% rehire rate.

B. Weaknesses Corrected since the Previous Visit

None were cited.

C. Weaknesses Continued from the Previous Visit

None were cited.

D. New Weaknesses

None were cited.


Back to Top


CATEGORY III: PROFESSIONAL EDUCATION FACULTY


A. Observations

Nearly all of the unit's professional education faculty in both the initial and advanced programs hold terminal degrees in their fields; all are qualified for their assignments. There are 117 full-time faculty and 200 adjunct faculty members. Fifty- one percent of the faculty have been hired since 1995. In 1995, 14.7% of the full-time faculty were minorities, while in 1999, 18.5% were minorities. Ninety-four faculty members are on tenure-track. The faculty is engaged in the professional community as teacher scholars. During the 1998-1999 academic-year, faculty members wrote and published 4 books, wrote 40 chapters for books, and published 75 articles in refereed journals. Faculty were also involved in making professional presentations and served in leadership positions in professional organizations at the state, regional , and national/international levels. Faculty were also involved in state and local education task forces, advisory councils, and initiatives

Numerous non-tenured faculty members are engaged in one day per week service in public schools. These faculty members have been assured that this level of involvement would not adversely effect tenure and promotion.

An overwhelming majority of adjunct faculty members hold terminal degrees and have expertise and experience in the areas in which they teach or supervise. An Adiunct/New Faculty Handbook is used to orient them to working in the College of Education. Adjunct faculty members are required to use a syllabus provided by the department chair.

The unit has implemented a Minority Faculty Recruitment Plan that was revised in June of 1998. The plan includes specific activities intended to attract minority applicants for positions within the unit. Some aspects of the plan include faculty networking with colleagues at other institutions of higher education to identify potential candidates, and the use of an Equal Employment Opportunity Search and Screen package. The process also includes advertisement in the Chronicle of Higher Education, advertisement in an appropriate publication oriented to a minority audience, and letters to professional contacts. The activities of the Minority Faculty Recruitment Plan Committee are well documented. Within the unit, there is a "Grow Your Own" program that recruits minority students to serve as instructors with free tuition and a salary while pursuing a doctorate. A tally of the current faculty indicated twenty-one minority members. Of this number, 7 are Blacks, 6 are Hispanics, 7 are Asian or Pacific Islanders, and 1 is Native American. Two of the six department chairpersons are members of a minority group

A companion piece to the Minority Faculty Recruitment Plan is a Retention Plan. This plan includes orientation for new faculty members, support from the department chair, and the assignment of a faculty mentor. All new faculty members have a minimum of one observation during the first year of employment. At the end of each academic year, a written assessment of "Progress Toward Tenure" is completed for each non-tenured faculty member until tenure is awarded at the University.

Each faculty member is assigned to teach nine semester hours each semester, and is expected to keep six office hours per week. The remainder of the faculty member's time is spent on research and service. The supervision of four student teachers/interns is equivalent to one course taught. Overloads are not recommended. Non-tenured faculty members are counseled about the possible negative impact that an overload may have on their progress toward tenure. There are clearly stated criteria for consideration for promotion and tenure. Faculty members are considered for promotion and tenure simultaneously; however, separate votes are taken.

There are opportunities for faculty development activities. The College supports faculty development if it addresses a programmatic need or individual professional development. The major sources of revenues for professional development are allocated from funds budgeted to a travel committee within the college of education. Funds are also available from the Dean's Office for faculty participation in professional development activities. Activities may also be funded through grants or at the personal expense of the faculty member. Leave for participation in professional development activities requires approval from the department chair and the Dean. The Area Center for Educational Enhancement has provided workshops for faculty members on topics such as Sunshine State Standards, the Florida Comprehensive Assessment Test, and Curriculum Planning Tool Software. The Information Resource Management Office offers free classes and faculty members may take tuition free courses within the university.

B. Weaknesses Corrected since the Previous Visit

Standard Ill. B (previously Standard IV.A):

There is no written plan for the continuing recruitment of a diverse faculty. Response-. The unit has implemented a Minority Faculty Recruitment Plan that includes a Retention Plan and was last revised in June of 1998.

C. Weaknesses Continued from the Previous Visit

None were cited.

D. Now Weaknesses

None were cited.


Back to Top


CATEGORY IV: THE UNIT FOR PROFESSIONAL EDUCATION


A. Observations

The College of Education has six departments: Counselor Education, Educational Leadership, Exceptional Student Education, Teacher Education, Health Sciences, and Educational Technology and Research. In conjunction with the University's reorganization, the role of department chair has changed from that of faculty to administration. Department chairs are now appointed by the dean of the College and serve for a period of three years at the dean's discretion.

There are insufficient numbers of full-time faculty to support programs although the number of faculty has increased since the last NCATE visit from 65 to 117. However, the number of new hires has not sufficiently kept up with the dramatic increase in enrollment.

Curriculum vitae for the adjuncts hired to teach courses and supervise clinical experiences document they are of extremely high quality but adjuncts are not available  to advise students and engage in College of Education and department committee work. There were 200 adjunct faculty hired for the 1999 fall semester.

Standing committees within the College of Education include the Executive Committee, Graduate Programs Committee, Undergraduate Programs Committee, Undergraduate Petitions Committee, Promotion and Tenure Committee, and a Library Committee. The College of Education's Promotion and Tenure Committee consists of one member from each department. This committee makes recommendations to the dean who forwards the committees recommendation to the provost as well as the University's Promotion and Tenure Committee.

There is a variety of advisory committees that support the faculty and administration of the College of Education. The Faculty Assembly, composed of all full- time tenure-track faculty within the College of Education, meets twice each semester. All academic departments have one member who serves on the steering committee. The Faculty Assembly establishes formal procedures for evaluating chairs, deans, and associate deans, however, the Faculty Assembly has little responsibility for governance because it is only advisory to the dean. The Advisory Council consists of representatives from seven school districts, private parochial schools, two students, ten members of the business community and additional members recommended by the chairperson. This Council meets with the dean four times a year. A student advisory committee acts as a liaison among students, faculty, and administration and is currently chaired by a doctoral student.

The College of Education and the other colleges at Florida Atlantic University have separate budgets for the other respective campuses [MacArthur and Treasure Coast campuses], the Boca Raton campus, and the southern (Davie/Broward campuses. The associate deans for each campus are responsible for the appropriation and monitoring of budget expenditures for their respective campuses. The allocation of funds is made by the campus vice presidents on the northern and southern campuses, and by the associate provost on the Boca Raton campus. The dean has complete authority and control of budgets and allocations on the Boca Raton campus. Funds can be moved from one budget category to another without the approval of the Associate Provost on the Boca Raton campus. On the northern and southern campuses, funds can be moved from one budget category to another only at the request of the respective campus vice president.

The unit has reactivated the Secondary Teacher Education Coordinating Committee [STECC]. This committee meets annually to give recommendations to the dean. The purpose of the committee is to engage the faculty outside of the College of Education in decision-making for the benefit of secondary education candidates and programs. Since meetings are held only once a year, there is limited opportunity for input or decision making.

A wide variety of technological resources is available to support faculty scholarship, teaching, and service. These include a computer on the desk of all faculty, Renaissance Technology Center, and professional development workshops to enable faculty to utilize technology for the advancement of teaching, scholarship, and service. Florida Atlantic University is a part of the Florida University Library system. Comprehensive library facilities are available on each of the campuses. Each campus has adequate numbers of education or related current books and journals. At the Boca Raton campus there are 38,460 books and 483 journals, the MacArthur campus has 7,500 books and 66 journals, the Treasure Coast campus has 1,439 books and 20 journals, and the Davie campus has 6,436 books and 159 journals. The S. E. Wimberly Library on Florida Atlantic University's Boca Raton campus houses new and innovative assistive technology workstations for persons with disabilities in the reference department. The equipment, which has ADA compliant software, is set up on new study carrels with extra high table tops to accommodate persons in wheelchairs.

B. Weaknesses Corrected since the Previous Visit

Standard IV.A [Previous Standard V.B]

There is excessive use and dependence on adjunct and regular FTE Faculty overloads to meet course and program demands.

Although there is a large number of adjuncts utilized, there are few faculty overloads. The number of adjuncts is addressed under resources for the unit.

C. Weaknesses Continued from the Previous Visit

Standard IV.A [Previous Standard V.A]

Faculty involved in professional education [particularly those who programs reside in colleges outside of the College of Education] are not provided with equal opportunities for a voice in the unit's decision making process.

Although STECC [Secondary Teacher Education Coordinating Committee] exists, it only meets annually which provides only limited opportunity for participation in the decision making process.

New Weakness

Standard IV.A

There are insufficient numbers of full-time faculty to support programs. Although there has been a significant increase in the number of new faculty, the hires have not kept up with the dramatic increase in enrollment.

Standard IV.C

Budget resources are not allocated directly and controlled by the College of Education on the Davie, MacArthur and Treasure Coast Campuses. The Dean of the College of Education receives a direct allocation for the Boca Raton campus. The College maintains complete control of these funds. However, the control is different on each of the other campuses.


Back to Top


PART III
SOURCES OF EVIDENCE


PERSONS INTERVIEWED

Administrators (University)

Dr. Anthony Catanese, President
Dr. Richard Osburn, Provost Dr. Nathan Dean, Vice Provost

Administrators (Campus)

Dr. Diane Alperin, Associate Provost, Boca Raton Campus
Dr. Robert Huckshorn, Vice President, North Campuses
Dr. Mary McBride, Vice President, Broward Campuses

Advisory Council

Mr. John Almond, Chair, Education Manager, Motorola Corporation
Ms. Cheryl Alligood, Associate Superintendent, Curriculum, Palm Beach County
Ms. Eleanor Baldwin, Retired from Broward County School System
Ms. Eleni Coukos, President, College of Education Student Advisory Council
Mr. Robert Howell, Retired from IBM, FL. DOE, Palm Beach County School Bd.
Dr. Joanne Kaiser, Chief Personnel Officer, Palm Beach County Schools
Ms. Judith Klinek, Principal, LoggersO Run Middle School, Boca Raton
Mr. Jon Levinson, President, REL Enterprises, Inc.
Ms. Darlene Nowocien, Assistant Principal, Pioneer Park Elementary
Mr. David Rinker, Rinker Foundation Dr. Bernard Shulman, Attorney School Board Palm Beach County Ms. Joyce Swaffield, Principal, Del Prado Elementary School Mr. Frank Vodolo, Middle School Coordinator, Broward School District

Alumni - Undergraduate/Graduate

Mr. Bob Barker
Ms. Mapy Brown
Ms. Michele Feldman
Ms. Myra Julian Ms. Catherine Lee
Ms. Pam Whigam
Mr. Frank Yelinek

Boca Raton High School

Ms. Diana Harris, Principal
Ms. Jean Wasko, Curriculum Specialist and former GATE Coordinator
Dr. Janet Benton, FAU Liaison
Mrs. Debbie Esposito - GATE Onsite Coordinator
Ms. Tina Garofalo, English Teacher
Miss Jennifer Quinn, English Teacher
Ms. Nancy Feinberg, Social Studies Teacher
Ms. Linda Mirro, FAU Student Intern

Broward County Consortium

Dr. Kathleen 0'Rourke
Dr. Robert Parks Ms. Robin Nowling
Ms. Donna Henderson

Broward County School Representatives

Dr. Mary Ann Butler-Pearson, Distance Learning Coordinator
Dr. Gloria Moss, Senior Tech Specialist Deans/Associate Deans
Dr, Jerry Lafferty, Dean - College of Education
Dr. Mary Lou Caldwell, Associate Dean - North Campuses
Dr. Robert Shockley, Associate Dean - Boca Raton Campus
Dr. John Wisenfeld, Dean - College of Science
Dr. Ingrid Johanson, Associate Dean - College of Science
Dr. Kenneth Keaton, Associate Dean - College of Arts and Letters
Dr. Dorothy Stetson, Associate Dean - College of Arts and Letters
Dr. John Childrey, Associate Dean - College of Liberal Arts

Department Chairs

Dr. Valerie Bristor, Teacher Education
Dr. William Nicoll, Counselor Education
Dr. Simon Ogamdi, Health Sciences
Dr. John Pisapia, Educational Leadership
Dr. Cynthia Wilson, Exceptional Student Education

Development

Ms. Karen Drumheller, Director

Educational Leadership - Graduate Programs

Dr. John Pisapia, Chair
Dr. Larry Decker
Dr. Lucy Gugliemino, Adult and Community Education
Dr. Pat Maslin-Ostrowski, School Leadership

Educational Technology and Research Department

Dr. John D. Morris, Chair
Dr. Ray Cafolla
Dr. Patsy Ceros-Livingston
Dr. Don Gorman
Dr. Khalid Hamza
Dr. William Hunt
Dr. Lieberman
Dr. Roberta Weber

Exceptional Student Education Undergraduate/Graduate

Dr. Mary Lou Duffy
Dr. Rangasamy Ramasamy
Dr. Claudia Rinaidi (Davie Campus)
Dr. Lydia Smiley
Dr. Ron Taylor
Dr. Beverly Warde

Faculty

Dr. Marlene Braunius, Teacher Education
Dr. Sue Kinzer - TEA Director
Dr. Richard Knee, Educational Technology
Dr. Robert Parks, Educational Leadership

Faculty Assembly

Dr. Alex Miranda, Chair- 1999-2000
Dr. Mary Lou Duffy, Secretary
Dr. Richard Maeder, Member
Dr. Carmen Morales-Jones, Member

GATE - Professional Development Schools

A.D. Henderson University School 

Dr. Sandy Tsurutome, Director
Dr. Steven Montes, Principal
Ms. Lorraine Cross, On-Site Coordinator

Acreage Pines Elementary School 

Mr. Steve Stills, Principal
Ms. Sandee Fleming, On-Site Coordinator

Boca Raton Community Middle School  

Mr. Mondy, Principal
Ms. Brenda Darr, On-Site Coordinator
Dr. Robert Bleicher, FAU Liaison

Boca Raton Community High School       

Ms. Diana Harris, Principal
Ms. Debbie Esposito, On-Site Coordinator
Dr. Janet Benton, FAU Liaison

Garden City Elementary       

Ms. Tina Eaker, On-Site Coordinator
Dr. Marie Holbein, FAU Liaison

Indian Pines Elementary School
Ms. Gail Pastercywk, Principal
Ms. Pam Cornett, On-Site Coordinator
Dr. Joseph Furner, FAU Liaison

Jeff Davis Middle School      

Ms. Sandy Jinks, Principal
Ms. Maribil Collin, On-Site Coordinator
Ms. Denise Ross

Palm City Elementary School
Ms. Nancy Marin, Principal       
Ms. Janet LeMaster, On-Site Coordinator

Pahokee Middle/Senior High School
Ms. May Gamble, Principal
Mr. Allen Canaan, FAU Liaison

Pioneer Park Elementary School
Ms. Anne Turner, Principal       
Ms. Shelly Miller, On-Site Coordinator
Dr. Marris Ward, FAU Liaison

Warfield Elementary School

Ms. Essie Rains, Principal
Ms. Jade Cheremis, On-Site Coordinator
Dr. Sharon Crawley, FAU Liaison

Gate (Continued)

Dr.William Nicoll, FAU
Dr. Toni Kirkwood
Dr. Sally Robinson

Genesis Program

Dr. Peter Messmore, Director
Dr. Janet Benton
Dr. Robert Beecher
Dr. Greg Brigman
Dr. Toni Carked
Dr. William Nicoll
Dr. Sally Robinson

Genesis - Students

Ms. Kimberly Gordon
Mr. Ryan H. Kasha
Mr. Scott Podradchik
Ms. Leila Revel
Ms. Jennifer Roesler
Ms. Suzanne Schweitzer

Graduate Programs Committee

Dr. John D. Morris, Committee Chair, Educational Technology and Research
Dr. Ali Danesh, Health Sciences
Dr. Carlos Diaz, Teacher Education
Dr. Mary Lou Duffy, Exceptional Student Education
Dr. Vasil Kerensky, Educational Leadership
Dr. Richard Knee, Educational Technology and Research
Dr. Ann Lynch, Counselor Education
Dr. Pat Maslin-Ostrowski, Educational Leadership
Dr. Alex Miranda, Counselor Education
Dr. Carmen Morales-Jones, Teacher Education

Graduate Students

Mr. Afsaneh Afshar, Early Childhood Certificate
Ms. Mindy Agier, Mental Health Counseling
Ms. Eileen Bayanati, Masters and Certification in VE
Ms. Raquel Byrne, Masters and Certification - Elementary Education
Ms. Eleni Coukos, Educational Leadership - Higher Education
Mr. Roderick Daniel, Multicultural Education w/ESOL Endorsement
Ms. Cassandra Ewald, Special Education - Doctoral Student
Ms. Jennifer Freeland, Educational Leadership K-12
Ms. Gianna Gouveia, Multicultural Foundations - Teacher Education
Ms. Deedara Hicks, Educational Leadership Ed.D.- Asst. Principal
Ms. Geri Mayer, Educational Leadership - Adult/Higher Education
Ms. Jessica Pruitt, Educational Leadership K-12
Ms. Carolyn J. Randall, Mental Health Counseling
Ms. Sonia Rodriquez, Executive Leadership Ed.D.
Ms. Jodi Schaffier, Multicultural Foundations - Graduate Program
Dr. Susan F. Schultz, Educational Leadership - Recent Graduate
Ms. Adrienne Stevens, School Counseling - Counselor Education

Grants

CARD Grant - Center for Autism and Related Disabilities
Dr. Jack Scoft

Multicultural Grants
Dr. Carlos Diaz

Partnership Grant
Dr. Greg Brigman

Holocaust Outreach Center

Dr. Ellen Heckler
Ms. Eileen Shapiro
Ms. Connie Packman

Library

Dr. William Miller, Director
Ms. Rita Pelien
Mr. Edward Erazo

Promotion and Tenure Committee

Dr. Lydia Smiley, Committee Chair, Exceptional Student Education
Dr. Sara Ashworth, Teacher Education
Dr. Richard Maeder, Counselor Education
Dr. Dale Williams, Health Sciences

Secondary Teacher Education Coordinating Committee (STECC)

Dr. Don Baird, Chemistry & Biochemistry
Dr. Janet Benton, English Education
Dr. Robet Bleicher, Science Education
Dr. John Childrey, English
Dr. Pete Fraschefti, Art Education
Dr. Jackie Gallagher, Geology (Earth Science)
Dr. Stuart Glazer, Music
Dr. Jerry Haky, Chemistry & Biochemistry
Dr. Mark Jackson, Chemistry & Biochemistry
Dr. Ken Keaton, A&L College Major, Social Science
Dr. Toni Kirkwood, Social Science Education
Dr. Lee Klingler, Mathematical Sciences
Dr. Stephen Locke, Mathematical Sciences
Dr. Fernando Medina, Physics
Dr. Carol Meltzer, Music Education
Dr. Carmen Morales-Jones, Foreign Languages Education
Dr. Sally Robison, Mathematics Education
Dr. Nancy Romance, ACEE
Dr. Kathy Russo, Art
Dr. Ron Schultz, Geography
Dr. Dorothy Stetson, Political Science
Dr. Herb Stewart, Biological Sciences
Dr. Erny Weiser, Languages & Linguistics

South Florida Center for Educational Leaders

Dr. John Pisapia

Students (Davie Campus)

Ms. Shannon Arias, Elementary Education S.A.
Ms. Charisse Chambers, Elementary Education - TEA, S.A.
Ms. Rina Correa, Elementary Education, B.A.
Ms. Lisa DaSilva
Ms. Ann Musgrove, Masters, Educational Technology, Doctoral in Leadership
Ms. Laynie Schurr, Exercise Science, M.S.

Student Teaching Interns

Ms. Jodi Honaker
Ms. Lisa MacLeod
Ms. Cami Marks
Ms. Pamela Pironti
Mr. Robert Shingler
Ms. Marci York

Student Teaching Supervisors

Ms. Brenda Frank, Broward County
Ms. Linda Grigg, Broward County
Dr. Maria McNamara, Palm Beach County
Ms. Kathy Ryberg, Palm Beach County

Teacher Education - Undergraduate/Graduate

Dr. Eileen Ariza
Dr. Robert Bliecher
Ms. Lorraine Cross
Dr. Pete Fraschefti
Dr. Marie Holbein
Dr. Toni Kirkwood-Tucker
Dr. Susan Lapp
Dr. Carol Meltzer
Dr. Carmen Morales-Jones
Dr. Angela Rhone
Dr. Sally Robinson
Dr. Felicia Romeo
Dr. Dilys Schoorman

Tri-institutional Committee

Dr. Peter Messmore, Chair
Mr. Phil Jackson
Dr. Robert Shockey
Mr. Ed Whipple
Dr. Jan Yates
Ms. Tunjarnika Coleman-Ferrell

Undergraduate Program Committee

Dr. Peggy Goldstein, Chair
Dr. Sue Graves

DOCUMENTS REVIEWED

AACTE/NCATE Yearly Reports, 1995-1999,13S
Academic Program/Budget Development Presentation, 2S
Action Plan Documentation: Elementary Education Plus ESOL Endorsement, 4S
Adjunct/New Faculty Handbook, IV
Adjunct Vitae, Educational Technology and Research, 17Y
Adjunct Vitae, Teacher Education Alliance, 21Y
Adjunct Vitae, Teacher Education 20Y
Adjunct Vitae, Counselor Education, 15Y
Adjunct Vitae, Educational Leadership, 16Y
Adjunct Vitae, Exceptional Student Education, 18Y
Adjunct Vitae, Health Sciences, 19Y
Admissions/Advising Sample Folders, 2P
Advisory Council Minutes: COE, 1G
Annual Reports: COE, past 5 years, 1S
Approvals & Requests to Go Beyond the 120 Credit Limit, 1
BOR Addendum Report (Spring 2000 Visit), 18S
Clinical Placements: Collaboration with Service Area Counties, Clinical Educator Training, 12P
Community Counseling Network, 15P
Community College Counseling and Advising Handbook, 24G
Comprehensive Faculty Vitae, Health Sciences, 11Y
Comprehensive Faculty Vitae, Teacher Education Alliance, 13Y
Comprehensive Faculty Vitae, Teacher Education, 12Y
Comprehensive Faculty Vitae, Educational Technology and Research, 9Y
Comprehensive Faculty Vitae - Educational Leadership, 8Y
Comprehensive Faculty Vitae - Counselor Education, 7Y
Comprehensive Faculty Vitae, Exceptional Student Education, 1OY
Conceptual Framework: Documentation in Field Experience Booklets, 20S
Conceptual Framework: Professional Preparation for A Diverse Society, 16S
Conceptual Framework: Sharing with Adjuncts, 19S
Course Rotation Schedules - Health Sciences, 7P
Course Rotation Schedules - Other Departments, 8P
Department of Education (DOE) Unit Review (Site Visit) Team Report, 1995, 8S
Department of Education (DOE) Program Review Team Report, 1995, 8S
Departmental Productivity Trends, 3S
Employer Survey of Graduates (newly developed), 17P
Employment Records of Graduates, 5P
Endowed Professorships (Major Gifts): Annual Reports, 25G
Endowments/Scholarships/Donations/Sponsored Research Samples, 23G
Executive Committee Minutes, 1996-1997, IB
Executive Committee Minutes, 1998-2000, 2B
Faculty Assembly Constitution / Bylaws & Minutes: COE, 9B
Faculty Development Plan & Samples, 8V
Faculty Assignment / Development & Evaluation Folio, 4V
Faculty Diversity by Departments, 2V Field Experience Handbooks/Guidelines/Placements, 9P
Florida's Gold Coast Report: Statistics of Palm Beach County, 14P
GATE Conference: Cooperative Learning, 9V
GATE Activity Summary / Position Paper: Professional Development Schools,3G
General Teaching Practices I & 11 (EDG 3324 & EDG 3325), 1OP
Genesis Grant Proposals, 4G
Genesis Quarterly Reports 1997-1999, 7G-9G
Genesis Action Research, 6G
Governance Documents: Faculty Assembly, BOR/UFF Collective Bargaining Agreement, 1OB
Graduate Faculty: Guidelines & Membership, 7V
Graduate Policies and Procedures Manual, 20P
Graduate Program Committee Minutes: COE, 15B
Graduating Senior Survey, 16P
Guided Field Experiences I & 11 (EDG 3321 & EDG 3322), IIP
Henderson (Alexander D.) University School, ISG
Holocaust Outreach Center: Reports, Holdings, Evaluations, 15G
Institutional Program Evaluation Plans (IPEP), 1999, 5S
Institutional Program Evaluation Plans (IPEP), 1997, 7S
Institutional Program Evaluation Plans (IPEP), 1998, 6S
International Partnerships, 2IG
Junior Achievement Partnership, 19G
Liaison Position between FAU and Broward County Public Schools, 22G
Merit Pay Plans & Faculty Assignment Report Form: Departments, 5V
Liaison Position between FAU and Broward County Public Schools, 22G
Merit Pay Plans & Faculty Assignment Report Form: Departments, 5V
Minority Faculty Recruitment Plan & Search Reports, 3V
Minutes: Teacher Education Alliance, 8B
Minutes: Department of Health Sciences, 6B
Minutes: Department of Educational Technology and Research, 4B
Minutes: Department of Exceptional Student Education, 5B
Minutes: Social Foundations Governance Committee, 13B
Minutes: Department of Teacher Education, 7B
Minutes: Department of Educational Leadership, 3B
Multicultural (Minority) Recruitment / Retention, IP
NCATE Third Year Review, May 1998,14S
NCATE Third Party Testimony & Public Announcements (Spring 2000 Visit), 15S
NCATE Continuing Accreditation Report (Spring 2000 Visit), 17S
NCATE Continuing Accreditation Visit Report, 1995, I IS
Pine Jog Environmental Education Center, 14G
Policies and Procedures Handbook: COE, 16B
Program Folio: Curriculum and Instruction PreKindergarten/Primary, M.Ed., 20
Program Folio: Curriculum and Instruction, M.Ed., 19
Program Folio: Undergraduate Music Certification, 8
Program Folio: Elementary Education, M.Ed., 21
Program Folio: School Counseling, M.Ed., Ed.S., 14
Program Folio: Undergraduate: Varying Exceptionalities, 2
Program Folio: Undergraduate: Elementary Education Plus ESOL Endorsement, 3
Program Folio: Undergraduate: Secondary English Certification, 4
Program Folio: Undergraduate: Secondary Foreign Language Certification, 5
Program Folio: Undergraduate Social Studies Certification, 6
Program Folio: Curriculum and Instruction, Ed.S., 23
Program Folio: Reading, M.Ed., 22
Program Folio: Exceptional Student Education, M.Ed., 17
Program Folio: Undergraduate Chemistry Certification, 10
Program Folio: Undergraduate Physics Certification, 11
Program Folio: Undergraduate Mathematics Certification, 12
Program Folio: Elementary Education Plus Certification, M.Ed., (submitted to DOE), 29
Minority Faculty Recruitment Plan & Search Reports, 3V
Minutes: Teacher Education Alliance, 8B
Minutes: Department of Health Sciences, 6B
Minutes: Department of Educational Technology and Research, 4B
Minutes: Department of Exceptional Student Education, 5B
Minutes: Social Foundations Governance Committee, 13B
Minutes: Department of Teacher Education, 7B
Minutes: Department of Educational Leadership, 3B
Multicultural (Minority) Recruitment / Retention, IP
NCATE Third Year Review, May 1998,14S
NCATE Third Party Testimony & Public Announcements (Spring 2000 Visit), 15S
NCATE Continuing Accreditation Report (Spring 2000 Visit), 17S
NCATE Continuing Accreditation Visit Report, 1995, IIS
Pine Jog Environmental Education Center, 14G
Policies and Procedures Handbook: COE, 16B
Program Folio: Curriculum and Instruction PreKindergarten/Primary, M.Ed., 20
Program Folio: Curriculum and Instruction, M.Ed., 19
Program Folio: Undergraduate Music Certification, 8
Program Folio: Elementary Education, M.Ed., 21
Program Folio: School Counseling, M.Ed., Ed.S., 14
Program Folio: Undergraduate: Varying Exceptionalities, 2
Program Folio: Undergraduate: Elementary Education Plus ESOL Endorsement, 3
Program Folio: Undergraduate: Secondary English Certification, 4
Program Folio: Undergraduate: Secondary Foreign Language Certification, 5
Program Folio: Undergraduate Social Studies Certification, 6
Program Folio: Curriculum and Instruction, Ed.S., 23
Program Folio: Reading, M.Ed., 22
Program Folio: Exceptional Student Education, M.Ed., 17
Program Folio: Undergraduate Chemistry Certification, 10
Program Folio: Undergraduate Physics Certification, 11
Program Folio: Undergraduate Mathematics Certification, 12
Program Folio: Elementary Education Plus Certification, M.Ed., (submitted to DOE), 29
Program Folio: Undergraduate Teacher Education Alliance (TEA - experimental program), 30
Program Folio: Genesis (experimental program, 5 years, secondary + education certification), 32
Program Folio: Adult Education Leadership, M.Ed., Ed.S., Ed.D., 16
Program Folio: Exceptional Student Education, Ed.D., 18
Program Folio: Undergraduate Biology Certification, 9
Program Folio: Undergraduate Art Certification, 7
Program Folio: Curriculum and Instruction, Ed.D., 24
Program Folio: Social Foundations, M.Ed., 25
Program Folio: Undergraduate & M.S., Exercise Science & Wellness, 26
Program Folio: Undergraduate Medical Technology, 27
Program Folio: Mental Health Counseling, M.Ed., Ed.S., 13
Program Folio: Communications Disorders, M.S., 28
Program Folio: School Leadership, M.Ed., Ed.S., Ed.D., 15
Program Folio: Educational Leadership Program (Review Prepared for DOE, Fall 1999), 31
Public School University Partnerships Survey for State University System, 2G
Region V: Center for Educational Enhancement: Trimester Reports, 13G
Region V: Center for Educational Enhancement: Handbook of Professional Development, 12G
Response to NCATE Continuing Accreditation Visit Report, 1995, 12S
Response to 1995 Teacher Education Program Review Report, 1995, IOS
Retention Rates, FAU, 3P Sample Exit Exams: Ed.S. & Ed.D., 18P
Schedules of Courses - 5 years, 6P
Slattery (Karen) Educational Research Center for Child Development, 17G
STECC (Secondary Teacher Education Coordinating Committee), IOG
STECC (Secondary Teacher Education Coordinating Committee) Documentation, 11G
Strategic Plan 2000: FAU, 17B
Student Assessment of Instruction, 10V
Student Teaching: Handbooks, Samples of Student Files, Samples of Units, 13P
Student Handbook: FAU, 19P
Student Assessment of Instruction (SAI), 1OV
Student Diversity, 4P
Summary Faculty Vitae - Counselor Education, IY
Summary Faculty Vitae - Health Sciences, 5Y
Summary Faculty Vitae - Exceptional Student Education, 4Y
Summary Faculty Vitae - Educational Technology & Research, 3Y
Summary Faculty Vitae - Educational Leadership, 2Y
Summary Faculty Vitae - Teacher Education, 6Y
Supervisors Vitae, 14Y
Sustained Performance Evaluation Plan: FAU, 6V
Teacher Education Alliance Partnership Agreement (TEA) & Advisory Council Members, 2OG
Technology Plans: College of Education and Departments, 11B
Technology Literacy Challenge Grant, 16G Technology (Renaissance) Lab Inventory, 12B
Undergraduate Program Committee Minutes: COE, 14B

 

FAU Campuses: Boca Raton/Davie/Dania Beach/Fort Lauderdale/Jupiter/Treasure Coast