Where are you from – really?


Borikén: Isla del Encanto

This is a question that both intrigues and concerns me. In such a diverse nation as the USA, some persons cannot accept that someone with my unique characteristics [physical, language, etc.] can be an “American.” So after being asked, “Where are you from?” and getting my response, “The USA,” I am often asked, “No, I mean, where are you really from?”

I am and have always been from the USA. I was born and raised a native-born USA citizen in the island of Puerto Rico. I do not immigrate to the USA; I migrate within my own country just like any other USA citizen migrates from, let’s say Florida to New York. Puerto Ricans are the largest “revolving door” migratory group in the USA, moving between the island and the mainland regularly and without restrictions. Puerto Ricans do not need passports or migration papers to move within their own country of birth – and they do not need resident or working papers.

What you were [probably] not taught in school.

Let me add a bit of history. Puerto Rico has been subjected to USA domination since the USA invaded the island in 1898. Puerto Ricans resisted but succumbed to the USA military power in 1900. The USA established a military government, with all governors – non Puerto Ricans - appointed by the USA President. The island was not allowed to elect its own island-born governor until 1948. The Jones Act of 1917 declared all Puerto Ricans citizens by Act of Congress – also against their will – with mandatory military service in WWI. This law also imposed English as the official language, mandating all instruction in English with Spanish offered only as a special subject. As a result, thousands of Puerto Ricans were forced to leave schools and migrate to mainland cities such as New York and Chicago to work in low-paying menial jobs.

The USA also changed the island’s name to Porto Rico and did not change it back until 1932. In 1952 the island became a territorial commonwealth of the USA. In this position, Puerto Rico controls only its internal affairs if/when they do not conflict with USA laws. The USA controls the island’s interstate trade, foreign relations and commerce, customs, control of air, land, and sea, immigration and emigration, nationality and citizenship, currency, maritime laws, military service, military bases [army, navy, and air force], declaration of war, constitutionality of laws, jurisdiction and legal proceedings, treaties, radio and television – communications, agriculture, mining and minerals, highways, postal system, social security, and many other areas controlled by the USA federal government. Yet, Puerto Ricans are not allowed to vote in USA Presidential elections and lack representation on either house of the USA Congress, except a “representative” in Washington that has no vote. The official definition for colonialism and neocolonialism explains why Puerto Ricans have challenged USA domination since 1898.

More things you probably did not learn in school: Puerto Rico today has one of the highest literacy and educational rates in the world. Education is a matter of high priority, representing 40% of the island’s budget. Literacy among persons aged 15 and over is 94.1%. Both Spanish and English are official languages and although public schooling is conducted in Spanish, English instruction is required at all levels and most Puerto Ricans are bilingual. Puerto Rico has over 50 institutions of higher education and has attained one of the highest college continuation and completion rates in the world (6th) with 56% of college-age students attending institutions of higher learning. According to the World Bank Data and the CIA, Puerto Rico provides the largest number of Ph.D.s in math, science, and engineering to USA businesses on the mainland. This should make anyone wonder why Puerto Ricans are doing so poorly in mainland USA schools.

Marta I Cruz (Cruz-Janzen), Ph.D.

Professor

Department of Teaching and Learning
Office Number: 561-297-3671
Office Location: Boca, 47 - ED 349

cruzjanz@fau.edu
Updated April 16, 2012